Need a sugar-free pumpkin pie? No problem. Avoiding gluten? No problem. Need a non-dairy pumpkin pie? No problem.
When I started making sugar-free pumpkin pie, it was for my mom, back in the 1970s. At that point, artificial sweeteners tasted so bad no one but my mom would eat the sugar-free version, so I made two pies. These days, the sweeteners have gotten better, and so has my cooking. Now I make sugar-free pie for everybody, and it vanishes, no problem. This year my pie will also be gluten-free. But I only need the one recipe. Here is how.
THE CRUST: I start with two frozen pie crusts, thawed but unbaked and ready to go. (The filling recipe below will fill two frozen pie crusts or one home-made or deep-dish frozen crust.)
Frozen crust is fine, especially for Thanksgiving when so much is going on. Almost all frozen pie crust is sugar-free. There are lots of choices, including gluten free, and all vegetable, whole wheat, and, kosher, and organic. With frozen crust, you can mix and match. This year I will make one gluten-free crust and one organic.
A note: Of course you can make your own crust. The basic ratio is 1 c. flour to 1/3 c. butter or margarine, and 1-2 T cold water. Cut the fat in with a pastry cutter, add the cold water, and make into a ball. (I do this with a food processor.) Let the dough rest for 30 minutes, roll it out, roll it onto rolling pin, put it on pie pan, crimp it, prick it, and by then you will be ready to lie down for a rest yourself. For a detailed how-to, consult any standard cook book.
For gluten-free crust, in theory you can try to substitute gluten-free all-purpose flour into recipe. If you plan to do this, do a “dry-run”. All purpose gluten-free flour is really a blend of several kinds of non-wheat flour, each brand is a different blend of flours and each will behave differently. Gluten-free flour doesn’t behave like regular flour, so you might need to adjust the amount of shortening, water, or flour to get the consistency right. Experience making regular pie crust will help. There are gluten-free pie crust mixes out there, and plenty of recipes to be found on the web, too. But unless you have a back-up plan and time for a do-overs, I would go with the frozen gluten-free crust for Thanksgiving.
THE FILLING: First, flavor and sweeten the pumpkin. Start with 2 cups (or 15 oz can) of pumpkin. Put it in a bowl and flavor with 1/2 t cinnamon, 1/4 t ginger, and 1/4 t allspice, and 1/2 t salt. Add 1 tsp vanilla. Then add 2 T maple syrup, or for sugar-free version, Vermont-Maid sugar-free syrup with Splenda. Mix well. Then add sugar or Splenda, about 3/4 c. Mix and taste. If you need it sweeter, add another 1/4 c of sugar or Splenda.
In a separate bowl, mix 2 eggs and 1 cup liquid, which can be light cream, evaporated skim milk, or non-dairy creamer. (Rich’s non-dairy creamer is also gluten-free and kosher.) Add to the pumpkin and mix very, very well.
Use a ladle to pour the filling into pie shells.
BAKING: Start with an oven pre-heated to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. After 15 minutes, lower the temperature to 350 and bake for about 50 minutes. It is done when you can stick the tip of a butter knife into the pie and it comes out clean.
WHIPPED TOPPING: Put a pint of real whipping cream in a small mixing bowl. Add 1 tsp vanilla and 1 or 2 T of sugar or Splenda, for sugar-free. The vanilla makes it tastes so good that you don’t need it any sweeter than that, and there is no gluten here either. Whip with a mixer until you get firm peaks, and it starts to look like whipped cream. Don’t whip it too long or you will make butter.
For dairy-free or pareve topping, Rich’s also makes a dairy-free whipped topping that is kosher pareve and gluten-free.
A NOTE ABOUT VEGAN PUMPKIN PIE:There are lots of recipes out there for you. Many of them substitute silken tofu for the dairy and eggs in the filling. The best one I saw was on the Whole Foods Web site, for a vegan pumpkin pie with a pecan crust. http://www.wholefoodsmarket.com/recipes/884
ONE PIE FOR ALL? Well, maybe not. Not everybody likes pumpkin pie! So I usually make an apple pie, too. But that’s a post for another day.
NOTE: If you are cooking for someone with Celiac disease, ask questions and check every product for gluten-free labels and certification. Check non-fat dairy products because added food-starch might contain gluten.
By Randa Dubnick
Image is “The Pi of Pie (Posterized Photo)” by Randa Dubnick. All rights reserved.